Shopify fees

How to Add Extra Fees Without Surprising Customers at Checkout

Andrey Gadashevich
Andrey Gadashevich

CEO | CRO Expert

How to Add Extra Fees Without Surprising Customers at Checkout

Most shoppers don't walk away over a $3 fee. They walk away over a $3 fee they didn't see coming.

The research backs that up. In Baymard Institute's checkout studies, 40% of US shoppers who abandoned an order for a real reason (not just browsing) said extra costs like shipping, tax and fees were too high, and 12% left because they couldn't see or calculate the total up front (Baymard Institute). Same fee. Different moment. Different outcome.

When we pulled every published fee from stores running Upcharge in November 2026 (8,213 of them), one number stood out. 86% are applied automatically, and only about 1 in 4 of those automatic fees has a description telling the shopper what it's for. That's thousands of charges showing up with a name, a price and nothing else.

Here's the playbook we'd hand any Shopify store before it adds a fee: what to call it, where to show it, which rules to check and how to test it.

Surprise costs more than the fee

The uncomfortable part first. Hiding fees works, at least for a while. In a large field experiment on StubHub, shoppers who saw fees only at checkout spent about 21% more and were 14% more likely to buy than shoppers who saw all-in prices from the first page (Blake, Moshary, Sweeney & Tadelis, Marketing Science).

That result is exactly why regulators went after the practice. California, the UK and the FTC have all moved against "drip pricing", which means showing one price and adding mandatory charges later. And the short-term bump comes with a long tail:

  • refund requests from customers who feel tricked

  • support tickets that all start with "what is this charge?"

  • reviews that talk about the fee instead of the product

  • repeat buyers who quietly shop somewhere else next time

A fee that's explained early is just part of the price. A fee that shows up late feels like a broken promise, even when it's $2.

Name the fee after the cost it covers

"Service fee." "Processing." "Additional charge." Names like these tell the shopper nothing, so the shopper fills the gap with the worst explanation available. Usually it's they're padding the bill.

Good fee names describe the cost:

→ Oversized item handling instead of "Surcharge"
→ Cold-pack shipping box instead of "Packaging fee"
→ Card processing (3%) instead of "Admin fee"
→ Engraving instead of "Customization charge"

Then add one sentence of why. Not a paragraph, just a line a shopper reads in two seconds: "Covers the extra-large box and two-person handling this sofa needs."

In Upcharge, that's the Fee title plus the Add a tooltip with a description option on the fee page. On desktop the description appears as a tooltip beside the fee. On mobile it shows inline, so it isn't stuck behind a hover nobody can do on a phone. The help center's Setting up Product fees guide walks through both fields.

Remember that 1-in-4 number? It means three out of four automatic fees in Upcharge stores run without a description. If you fix one thing after reading this, add the description.

Show the fee before checkout, not at it

Checkout is the worst place to meet a new charge. By then the shopper has a price fixed in their head, and anything above it reads as a hike.

So put the fee where decisions get made:

  1. On the product page. If a product always carries a fee (a bottle deposit, an oversized item charge), mention it in the product description near the price. One short line does the job: "+ $45 oversized handling, added in cart."

  2. In the cart. That's where Upcharge shows online store fees, so the total a shopper sees before pressing Checkout already includes them. For automatic fees, the Fee display in cart setting lets you show the charge as a line above the subtotal or as a separate cart item, and percentage product fees can also be shown inside the product's own line.

  3. With a notice for anything automatic. Shopify requires apps that add required fees to tell shoppers a charge was added. Upcharge shows a short banner near the subtotal ("Required [fee name] added. Included in total."), and you can rewrite the wording under Settings → Texts & Translations (how it works).

On Shopify Plus you can also charge fees at checkout itself. That's useful for duties that depend on the shipping address, which the cart doesn't know yet. But for anything you could show earlier, show it earlier. Checkout-only fees should be the exception. Not sure which level a fee belongs on? Read cart-level vs product-level fees and product fees vs shipping fees.

Keep optional fees optional

Gift wrap, rush processing, shipping insurance, an extended warranty: a shopper chooses these. They should start unselected.

A pre-ticked box turns a choice into a trap. The shopper has to notice it and undo it, and the ones who don't notice find out on their card statement. The FTC's fee rule spells out the honest version: charges for optional goods or services can sit outside the upfront total, but they must be clearly disclosed before you ask for payment (FTC FAQ).

In Upcharge:

  • set Fee application to Selected by customer

  • pick the input that fits the choice: a checkbox for yes/no, a dropdown or radio buttons for tiers, a date field for scheduled delivery

  • don't mark an option as the default on a checkbox fee, because a checkbox fee with a default option is applied automatically, which is exactly the pre-ticked box you're trying to avoid

  • turn on Require customer selection only when the shopper genuinely has to choose (standard vs express handling, say), not to push an upsell

Every input type is covered in Displaying fees.

Check which pricing rules apply to you

Fee rules are tightening, and they don't all say the same thing. The short version for an online store:

Where

What it says about fees

In force since

California (SB 478)

Advertised prices must include mandatory fees. Taxes, reasonable shipping and optional add-ons can be left out, but handling charges can't (California Attorney General)

July 1, 2024

United Kingdom (DMCC Act)

Drip pricing of mandatory charges is banned. Admin, booking and processing fees count as mandatory, whatever you call them (CMA guidance)

April 6, 2025

US federal (FTC fees rule)

Total-price rule for live-event tickets and short-term lodging only. Optional charges must be disclosed before payment (FTC)

May 12, 2025

What this means in practice: if a fee is mandatory and you sell to consumers in California or the UK, the first price shoppers see should already include it. That pushes every-order costs into the product price and leaves fees for what they're good at: optional extras, and charges triggered by the shopper's own choices, like rush delivery or a remote address. We break that decision down in product surcharges vs price increases.

Card surcharges have a rulebook of their own (Visa, for one, requires merchants to notify their acquirer 30 days before they start), which our surcharges guide covers. None of this is legal advice. If a fee is central to your pricing, run it past a lawyer who knows your markets.

Test every path, express buttons included

A fee that works on your laptop in your country can still surprise someone on a phone in another one. Before you call it done, shop your own store like a stranger:

  1. Open a private window and buy the normal way: product page, cart, checkout.

  2. Check it on a phone. Descriptions show inline on mobile, so make sure they still read well at that size.

  3. Try the express buttons. On stores without Shopify Plus, Buy it now, Shop Pay, Apple Pay and Google Pay skip the cart, so cart fees can be skipped too. Turn on Hide dynamic checkout buttons under Settings → General, or use checkout-only fees on Plus (details here).

  4. Test from another country if the fee uses location rules. Online store fees with Geography settings go by the visitor's IP address, and when the country can't be detected, the fee doesn't apply (Geography settings).

  5. Read the order confirmation. The fee should appear under the same name the shopper saw in the cart.

  6. Check your translations if you sell in more than one language (translating fees).

[ADD: one thing your support team sees most often when a merchant skips this test, e.g. the express-button case]

What to do now

Open your fee list and sort it into two piles: fees a shopper chooses, and fees a shopper can't avoid.

For the first pile, make sure every option starts unselected and carries a one-line description. For the second pile, ask the harder question: should this just be in the price? If it stays a fee, give it a name that explains itself, show it in the cart, and add that tooltip today.

Starting from zero? How to add extra fees to Shopify products walks through setup step by step, and Upcharge on the Shopify App Store comes with a 14-day free trial. A fee shoppers understand is a fee they'll pay.

FAQ

Are hidden fees at checkout illegal?

It depends on where and what you sell. California's SB 478, in force since July 1, 2024, requires most mandatory fees to be included in the advertised price; taxes, reasonable shipping and optional add-ons can be left out. In the UK, the DMCC Act bans drip pricing of mandatory charges. The FTC's federal fees rule covers only live-event tickets and short-term lodging. This isn't legal advice, so check your markets with a lawyer.

Why do extra fees cause cart abandonment?

In Baymard Institute's research, 40% of US shoppers who abandoned a checkout for a reason other than browsing said extra costs like shipping, tax and fees were too high, and 12% left because they couldn't see or calculate the total up front. A fee that appears late reads as a price hike, even when it's small. Showing it early, with a plain name and a reason, removes most of that shock.

Should optional fees be pre-selected at checkout?

No. An optional fee such as gift wrap or shipping insurance should only be added when the shopper picks it. A pre-ticked box makes the shopper spot and undo a charge they never asked for, and the ones who miss it find out on their statement. In Upcharge, set the fee to Selected by customer and don't mark a default option on checkbox fees.

Do Shopify express checkout buttons skip app fees?

They can. On stores without Shopify Plus, Buy it now, Shop Pay, Apple Pay and Google Pay send shoppers straight to checkout, so fees calculated in the cart can be skipped. Upcharge has a Hide dynamic checkout buttons setting under Settings, General that routes shoppers through the cart. On Shopify Plus, checkout-only fees apply however the shopper checks out.

Create your first product fees, surcharges and tariffs

Join thousands of merchants using UpCharge to charge for additional services

Create your first product fees, surcharges and tariffs

Join thousands of merchants using UpCharge to charge for additional services

Add fees, surcharges, tariffs, add-ons to boost sales and AOV

Company

Contacts

2810 N Church St 873907 Wilmington, Delaware 19802 United States

Add fees, surcharges, tariffs, add-ons to boost sales and AOV

Company

Contacts

2810 N Church St 873907 Wilmington, Delaware 19802 United States

Add fees, surcharges, tariffs, add-ons to boost sales and AOV

Company

Contacts

2810 N Church St 873907 Wilmington, Delaware 19802 United States